Milford Bakery Co. in Milford

Too bad they only do pasties on Wednesday

Great service and even better treats!

Awesome Place.

They have the best pasties around. Staff is always friendly.

Delicious cupcakes and cake

Best salt rising bread around! Everything tastes so good from here. I've never had a better custard filled donut!

Great local donut store! Good prices.

Not a very good place for custom cakes. We had a cake made where the topper was suppose to be made with fondant, but when we picked it up the topper was made with cardboard and didn't look good at all. And the cupcakes had a crown drawn on top that had zero consistency. There was not 2 cupcakes that looked the same.I read a review saying it's the best bakers in Milford, it's actually the only bakers in milford. As for it being affordable, it is. But you get what you pay for. The taste would get a much higher rating, but we figured we were paying a higher price for the aesthetics. For a plain looking cake or cupcakes we might go back again, but for a cool kids cake with designs we won't go here again.

They always have the freshest bakery goods. I always order my cakes from there and my family goes crazy for them. They rave about how it is decorated but most of all the taste of the cake. The cherry nut is to die for

My nephew buys me my birthday cake from here and i do cake all the time its nice to have a fresh great tasting cake made for me

Had gotten an amazing wedding cake here years ago (under a different owner?). Thought about getting an anniversary cake but was really disappointed in the flavor, cost, and options now. Cakes now taste generically super sweet like a grocery store cake. Very sad to see the heights they've fallen from.

We getting all our cakes made here for the kids' parties and special events. Its a little pricey but worth it. Wish they offered some kind of discount for repeat customers.

We used Milford Baking Co for our June 13, 2015 wedding desserts and they were awesome!! We actually had donuts, cookies and cupcakes for 200 guests as well as a small cake for my husband and I to cut and they were still reasonably priced. Our guests raved at how delicious they all were and loved the detail they put into the desserts. I would definitely recommend them for your baking needs. Also - I had a very hard time finding a baker who could do all three donuts, cookies and cupcakes. Most I found only do cookies and cakes or just donuts not all three. I appreciated having one baker do all three for us.

Great pasties, good price

We used the Milford bakery for our wedding in October 2015. It was an amazing Cake my husband loved it. I personally am not a big fan of cake but this was the best cake i have ever had. We will defiantly come back.

Cake was great, but was decorated in a bunch of uneditable items. I've never had a cake that required so much "undressing" just to cut the cake. Like why the hell is my cake wrapped in ribbon? Also, the person who sold me the cake was very condescending in trying to tell me "white" is not a flavor of cake. The last time I checked in with my local peasant group, acceptable cake styles are white, yellow, and chocolate. Apparently I'm just super uneducated, and rather than them just knowing what I meant, because who doesn't know what I mean when I say white cake, they felt the need to point out my ignorance.

Does not inforce social distancing. People breath all over you.

Had a cake done here over the weekend. It was super cute however it tasted horrible. I have more the half a cake left over because guests said the frosting tasted weird. The kids wouldn't even eat it.

When my daughter comes to town she demands their sugar cookies!! Also their donuts are the bomb!

Fun stop for grandkids

I have gotten my sons first and second birthday cakes from here. I have also stopped by often to pick up random treats. Their custom cakes are amazing and affordable. We will be continuing to get cakes from here.

Ordered a birthday cake for my husband the day of and it was perfect. Did a fantastic job when I didn't have time to.

Opens at 6am and always fresh.

Best paczki in town and when it's not Fat Tueday, I love the apple tuenover. Deffinately worth the visit. Great service too always friendly.

Been going here since I was a kid. Loved watching them in the kitchen. Awesome doughnuts and cakes. Classic Milford gem that's hopefully here to stay.

This is one of the best businesses around. The cake I ordered was not only beautiful, but tasted delicious! I can’t wait for the next party! All of the staff I spoke with were attentive, kind and professional. Thank you so much Milford Baking Company.

Great cakes. Can't beat em

There’s nothing quite like homemade baked goods & this Milford bakery is definitely up there! I love their soft, frosted sugar cookies personally & they have cute designs that change depending on the time of year. There is a minimum for cards, so be sure to bring cash if you’re just getting something small!

Unfortunately 3 days before my granddaughters grad party her best friend was a positive on Covid and Jane, my granddaughter is totally symptomatic of it. The party was canceled. Milford Bakerey refunded in full my total order of $375.00. What a wonderful gesture. It was only 3 days away. I can’t say enough about how wonderful they are. This is the company that did my daughters wedding cake, and shower cake.. A wonderful place to do business with and the cakes are wonderful. Thank you so much!

Called in an order for a cake only a few days during the middle of the Milford Festival... Still came out beautiful... Excellent Product and Service...

Cake flips are the bomb! My daughter loves all the sugar cookies. Fair pricing, lots of yummy treats to choose from!

Skip it. You're not missing much. Slow service, not enough inventory. Pass.

We’ve ordered every cake for my daughters birthdays here and special occasions and they are great tasting. We try to support local small businesses, however the employees are so very rude here. They don’t thank you and if you just want to stop in for a cookie they will treat you like you need to spend more money. We stopped in yesterday for some donuts and we sat down to eat for 5 minutes and the rude lady came out from the back and yelled at the lady working the register for not knowing the correct price. Then a guy came in and asked for a clean place to sit and she told him they had no clean water to wash the table with. Good cakes, very poor customer service. Not what I wish for downtown Milford.

Amazing bakery, has the BEST cookies and doughnuts ever. Been going there ever since I was a kid and I wouldn't even think about going somewhere else.

I grew up going to the bakery for their frosted cookies and chocolate milk. I still like to get them from time to time. The pasties are another one of my favorites!

The sugar cookies, with butter cream icing, are a must have.

Without a doubt, my favorite place to get donuts! The people behind the counter are always smiling, and the donuts are to die for. Cake donuts covered with sprinkles are a personal favorite.

This place is a staple in the Milford community. I have gone here since I was a kid. The staff is wonderful and their treats are amazing! The pricing is very fair as well. There is parallel street parking in the front of the building, or there is a large parking lot at the back of the storefronts, with handicap parking spots available. I would definitely check it out if you havent already.

The best pasties around,and awesome Christmas cookies..

I’ve order a jack daniels themed cake from them, cupcakes for a surprise 50th bday and engagement party sugar cookies. Everything has always been wonderful! I’ve ordered short notice and they’ve always taken care of me. The baked goods are delicious and their awesome designs are always a hit. Staff is friendly and patient. This is my go to baking company for anything!

The bakery has always been a classic. Fresh coffee and great goodies to eat!

Used Milford baking company for my wedding, my wedding cake and cupcakes were beautiful and of course all our guest loved and enjoyed the deserts. I was very happy!! Thank you.

Small friendly place with great treats. Not a lot of seating, and can get busy if people are picking up cakes, etc.

best place around!

I ordered a gender reveal cake & it couldn't have turned out more perfect! It looked exactly like the picture & it was exactly what I ordered and tasted even better than I could have imagined! Everyone loved it & I will continue to recommend my friends and family forever!

Always good cookies

Service was great! The donuts were delicious will have to go again when I am in town.

Lemon meringue was SO good, I haven't had my donut or Oreo cookie yet, but I'm excited to eat them!